Dissecting statistical genomics and psychiatric epidemiology...
Fiction Review CriteriaV1
C1 PLOT
C2 SETTING
C3 PERSPECTIVE
C4 STYLE
C5 CHARACTERS
C6 THEME
C7 ORIGINALITY
C8 IMPRESSIONS
C9 IMMERSION
Full explanation of the Fiction Review CriteriaV1 can be found here.
C1 PLOT
Plot is engaging and dynamic. The use of devices is purposeful and appropriate. Narrative follows a logical cause-and-effect sequence and there are no jarring plot holes.
C2 SETTING
Time and geographic location are well described and provide an immersing experience. The setting makes sense in the context of the plot. Any worldbuilding is done in a manner consistent with the overall purpose and the plot of the book.
C3 PERSPECTIVE
The choice and use of perspectives is enriching the text. Changes in perspectives are easily recognizable and are not affecting the overall flow. Perspectives are not distracting from the plot.
C4 STYLE
Stylistic and literary devices are supporting the plot and are helping convey emotions or provide insight. Devices are used with purpose. The sentences are not too long or overly ornate. Use of complex language is intentional.
C5 CHARACTERS
Characters are behaving logically with respect to their construction. Characters are multifaceted and not one-dimensional. Characters are not excessively introduced at random and without purpose, their motivations and relationships are clear. Character descriptions focus on aspects relevant to the plot.
C6 THEME
The author is conveying an underlying message or concept. There is depth to text.
C7 ORIGINALITY
There is originality to the text. The text is not formulaic and predictable.
C8 IMPRESSIONS
The text leaves lasting impression. The plot and the characters are memorable. The text evokes thought.
C9 IMMERSION
The text is written in an immersive manner. Sufficient details are provided to allow the readers to picture themselves in the story, yet details are not overwhelming or unnecessarily complex.
Nonfiction Review CriteriaV1
C1 ACCURACY AND RELIABILITY
C2 CLARITY AND ORGANIZATION
C3 SCOPE AND DEPTH
C4 PERSPECTIVE AND BIAS
C5 ENGAGEMENT AND STYLE
C6 ORIGINALITY AND CONTRIBUTION
C7 EVIDENCE AND ARGUMENTATION
C8 CONTEXT AND RELEVANCE
C9 IMPACT AND EFFECTIVENESS
Full explanation of the Nonfiction Review CriteriaV1 can be found here.
C1 ACCURACY AND RELIABILITY
Facts presented are accurate, well-researched, and supported by credible sources. There are no significant factual errors, misrepresentations, or biases skewing the information.
C2 CLARITY AND ORGANIZATION
Writing style is clear, concise, and accessible to the intended audience. Headings, subheadings, and transitions are used effectively to support communication and organization of the book.
C3 SCOPE AND DEPTH
The book adequately covers its stated topic. The book provides a sufficient depth and detail. It is not too superficial. The book explores the complexities of the subject.
C4 PERSPECTIVE AND BIAS
Author has a point of view and argument. The intent is clear, if not explicitly stated. While the intent is clear, the book is generally fair and balanced. Author presents different perspectives on the subject and there is no excessive cherry-picking of data to support a particular viewpoint.
C5 ENGAGEMENT AND STYLE
Writing style is compelling and interesting. The author uses effective storytelling techniques, vivid language, and other literary devices to hold the reader’s attention. The work is engaging.
C6 ORIGINALITY AND CONTRIBUTION
The book offers a fresh perspectives and/or novel insights on the subject matter. The book contributes something new to the existing body of knowledge and is not simply rehashing old information.
C7 EVIDENCE AND ARGUMENTATION
Author uses evidence and argumentation to support their claims. Arguments are logical, well-reasoned, and persuasive. Counterarguments are addressed.
C8 CONTEXT AND RELEVANCE
The book relates to the broader context of the subject matter. It addresses relevant contemporary issues or historical events. The book holds significance for readers today.
C9 IMPACT AND EFFECTIVENESS
The book achieved its purpose. It informed, educated, enlightened, and/or persuaded the reader. The book left lasting positive impressions or changed reader’s thinking on the subject.